The infield fly rule is one of the most misunderstood rules in baseball. It is designed to prevent the defense from gaining an unfair advantage by intentionally allowing an easily catchable fair fly ball to drop so that runners can be forced out.
When the required conditions are met, the umpire may declare “Infield Fly”, and the batter is automatically out. The ball remains live, meaning runners can still advance at their own risk.
In this guide, we explain the infield fly rule, when it applies, what happens to the runners, and common situations that often confuse players and fans.
What Is the Infield Fly Rule?
The infield fly rule is a baseball rule that protects runners when there are fewer than two outs and runners are on first and second base, or first, second, and third base.
If a batter hits a fair fly ball that an infielder can catch with ordinary effort, the umpire can declare an infield fly.
Once the umpire declares the infield fly:
- The batter is automatically out.
- The ball remains live.
- Runners do not have to advance.
- Runners may attempt to advance at their own risk.
- The defense cannot intentionally drop the ball to create a force-play advantage.
The rule is primarily designed to prevent an easy double play or triple play caused by an intentionally dropped fly ball.
When Does the Infield Fly Rule Apply?
The infield fly rule does not apply to every fly ball. Several conditions must exist.
1. There Must Be Fewer Than Two Outs
The rule can apply with:
- No outs
- One out
It does not apply when there are already two outs because the inning would end after the batter is retired.
2. There Must Be Runners on First and Second
The traditional situation is runners on:
First base + Second base
It can also apply when the bases are loaded:
First base + Second base + Third base
However, it does not apply when there is only a runner on first base.
3. The Ball Must Be Fair
The batter must hit a fair fly ball.
A foul fly ball cannot result in an infield fly declaration.
If the ball initially appears to be an infield fly but becomes foul before reaching the appropriate location, the umpire handles the play according to the applicable foul-ball rules.
4. The Ball Must Be Catchable With Ordinary Effort
The ball must be one that an infielder could catch with ordinary effort.
This is an important part of the rule.
A ball that requires an exceptional running catch, diving catch, or difficult defensive play generally should not be treated as an infield fly simply because it goes into the infield area.
The rule is based on the nature of the catch, not simply where the ball lands.
Why Was the Infield Fly Rule Created?
Imagine there are runners on first and second with one out.
The batter hits a high pop-up directly toward an infielder.
The infielder could easily catch it, but instead intentionally lets it fall.
The runners may have to wait to see whether the ball is caught. If it drops, the defense could potentially pick up the ball and force one or both runners at the next bases.
This creates an unfair advantage for the defense.
The infield fly rule prevents that strategy.
By declaring the batter out immediately, the force-play situation created by the batter’s out is removed. The runners can decide whether they want to remain on their bases or attempt to advance.
What Happens When the Umpire Calls “Infield Fly”?
When the umpire declares an infield fly, the batter is out immediately.
The ball does not become dead.
This distinction is extremely important.
For example:
- Runner on first
- Runner on second
- One out
- Batter hits a high fair pop-up
- Umpire declares “Infield Fly”
The batter is out.
If the ball is caught, runners may tag up and advance according to the normal rules.
If the ball is dropped, the ball remains live and runners may attempt to advance.
Does the Ball Become Dead After an Infield Fly?
No.
An infield fly is a live-ball situation.
The defense can still:
- Catch the ball
- Throw to a base
- Attempt to tag a runner
- Make other defensive plays
Runners can also attempt to advance.
The automatic out applies to the batter, not to the runners.
Do Runners Have to Run on an Infield Fly?
No.
Runners do not have to advance simply because an infield fly has been called.
This is one of the biggest differences between an infield fly and a normal force-play situation.
Because the batter is already out, runners can decide whether advancing is worth the risk.
For example, if there are runners on first and second and the batter hits an infield fly, the runner on second does not have to run to third simply because the ball is in the air.
Can Runners Advance on an Infield Fly?
Yes.
The ball remains live, so runners can attempt to advance.
However, they can be put out if they are:
- Tagged while off the base
- Forced into a situation where a force play applies
- Otherwise retired under the applicable rules
Runners should therefore understand that “Infield Fly” does not mean “stop the play.”
What Happens If the Infield Fly Is Caught?
If the ball is caught, the batter is out and runners may attempt to advance after properly tagging their original bases.
For example:
- Runner on first
- Runner on second
- One out
- Batter hits an infield fly
- Fielder catches the ball
The batter is out.
If the runner on second wants to advance to third, the runner generally must properly tag the original base before advancing because the ball was caught.
What Happens If the Infield Fly Is Dropped?
If the fielder drops the ball, the batter remains out because the infield fly was declared.
The ball remains live.
This is one of the most important aspects of the rule.
Suppose there are runners on first and second with one out. A fair pop-up is declared an infield fly, but the shortstop drops it.
The batter is still out.
The runners are not automatically out.
They can choose whether to advance, and the defense can attempt to make plays on them.
What Is the Difference Between an Infield Fly and a Regular Fly Ball?
The main difference is the situation and the automatic batter out.
| Situation | Regular Fly Ball | Infield Fly |
|---|---|---|
| Batter automatically out if ball is dropped | No | Yes |
| Ball must be fair | Not always | Yes |
| Runners required on first and second/bases loaded | No | Yes |
| Fewer than two outs required | No | Yes |
| Ball remains live | Usually | Yes |
| Designed to prevent intentional defensive drops | No | Yes |
What Is the Difference Between an Infield Fly and a Line Drive?
A line drive generally does not qualify as an infield fly.
The infield fly rule is intended for a qualifying fly ball that can be caught with ordinary effort.
A sharply hit line drive is treated differently under the applicable rules.
This is why the umpire must judge the type of batted ball and whether it meets the conditions for an infield fly.
Does the Infield Fly Rule Apply to a Bunt?
Generally, a bunt is not treated as an infield fly for purposes of the rule.
This is important because the infield fly rule is specifically designed around qualifying fly balls, not ordinary bunt situations.
If you are unsure whether a particular batted ball qualifies, the umpire’s judgment and the official baseball rules control.
What Does “Ordinary Effort” Mean?
Ordinary effort is one of the most important concepts in the infield fly rule.
It means the fielder should be able to make the catch through normal defensive effort considering the circumstances of the play.
It does not necessarily mean:
- The ball must be hit directly to the shortstop.
- The ball must stay on the dirt.
- Only an infielder can catch it.
- The ball must land inside the traditional infield.
An outfielder may sometimes be in a position to catch a qualifying fly ball, depending on the circumstances.
The key question is whether the ball is one that can reasonably be caught with ordinary effort.
Does the Umpire Have to Say “Infield Fly”?
The umpire should announce the infield fly when the conditions are met so that players and runners understand that the batter has been declared out.
The declaration is particularly important because the ball remains live and the runners need to know how the play is being treated.
You may hear an umpire say:
“Infield fly, batter’s out!”
If the ball is near the foul line, the umpire may also use the appropriate foul-related wording depending on the play.
Common Infield Fly Rule Examples
Example 1: Runners on First and Second
There is one out.
The batter hits a high pop-up to the shortstop. The shortstop can easily make the catch.
The umpire declares an infield fly.
Result: The batter is out. The ball remains live, and the runners can decide whether to advance.
Example 2: Bases Loaded
There is one out and the bases are loaded.
The batter hits a high fair pop-up that an infielder can catch with ordinary effort.
Result: The infield fly rule can apply. The batter is out even if the fielder drops the ball.
Example 3: Runner Only on First
There is one out and only a runner on first.
The batter hits a high pop-up.
Result: The infield fly rule does not apply because the required runner configuration is not present.
Example 4: Two Outs
There are two outs with runners on first and second.
The batter hits a high pop-up.
Result: The infield fly rule does not apply because there are already two outs.
Example 5: Difficult Catch
There are runners on first and second with one out.
The batter hits a fly ball into shallow left field that requires the fielder to make a difficult running catch.
Result: The infield fly rule may not apply because the catch may require more than ordinary effort.
Common Questions About the Infield Fly Rule
Can the infield fly rule be called with bases loaded?
Yes. The rule can apply with runners on first, second, and third, provided the other conditions are satisfied.
Can the infield fly rule be called with a runner only on first?
No. The required force-play configuration is not present.
Can the infield fly rule be called with two outs?
No. The rule applies only when there are fewer than two outs.
What if the fielder drops an infield fly?
The batter remains out. The ball remains live, and the runners can advance at their own risk.
Can runners advance on an infield fly?
Yes. The ball remains live, so runners may attempt to advance.
Is an infield fly automatically a dead ball?
No. The ball remains live.
Does the batter have to be called out before the ball is caught?
The umpire’s declaration of the infield fly makes the batter out under the rule. The defense does not need to successfully catch the ball to record the batter’s out.
Can an outfielder catch an infield fly?
The rule is not limited simply to a ball being caught by a traditional infielder. The relevant consideration is whether the ball qualifies under the rule, including whether it can be caught with ordinary effort.
Why Is the Infield Fly Rule Important?
The infield fly rule protects the offensive team from a defensive strategy that could otherwise create an unfair double-play opportunity.
It also makes baseball easier to understand by removing the incentive for a fielder to intentionally drop a routine fly ball.
The rule essentially says:
If the defense can easily catch a qualifying fly ball in a force-play situation, the batter can be declared out before the defense benefits from intentionally dropping it.
Final Takeaway
The infield fly rule is designed to protect runners from an unfair defensive advantage.
Remember these key conditions:
- There must be fewer than two outs.
- There must be runners on first and second, or the bases must be loaded.
- The batter must hit a fair fly ball.
- The ball must be catchable with ordinary effort.
- The umpire declares the batter out.
- The ball remains live.
- Runners can advance at their own risk.
Understanding these conditions makes one of baseball’s most confusing rules much easier to follow.
Related Baseball Rules to Learn Next
- What is a force play in baseball?
- What is a tag play in baseball?
- What is a dropped third strike?
- What is a balk in baseball?
- What is obstruction in baseball?
- What is batter’s interference?
- What is defensive interference?
- Can a runner leave early?
- What is an appeal play?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the infield fly rule in simple terms?
It allows the umpire to declare the batter out on certain easy-to-catch fair fly balls when there are runners on first and second or the bases are loaded with fewer than two outs.
Why does the infield fly rule exist?
It prevents fielders from intentionally dropping an easy fly ball to create an unfair force-play or double-play opportunity.
Does an infield fly have to be caught?
No. Once the umpire properly declares an infield fly, the batter is out even if the fielder drops the ball.
Can runners run on an infield fly?
Yes. The ball remains live, so runners may attempt to advance, but they can be retired according to the applicable rules.
Does the infield fly rule apply with one runner on first?
No. The required base-runner configuration is not present.
Does the infield fly rule apply with two outs?
No. The rule applies only with fewer than two outs.
Is an infield fly a dead ball?
No. The ball remains live after the batter is declared out.
What does ordinary effort mean in the infield fly rule?
It refers to a catch that a fielder can reasonably make through normal defensive effort under the circumstances of the play.


